A blogger’s response to Hale – #haleno

05 Nov

hale new header

A Blogger’s response to Hale’s article “Are you a catfish reviewer?”

It’s been about 3 weeks now since the Guardian posted an article by author, Kathleen Hale, titled “Am I being catfished?’ – an author confronts her number one critic. As I read through the article, a very long and detailed article, I felt a sickening feeling develop in my stomach. In this article, the author describes her reaction to receiving a one-star review and the steps that she took the address this issue. I’m not going to recount everything that occurred, as there are other authors and bloggers who have discussed it much more succulently than I can.

Alex Hurst’s Hale vs Harris, and the Breach of Online Ethics” and The Moonlight Reader – When Manipulation Masquerades as Memoir: The #HaleNo edition provide good summaries of the events, as does Dear Author – ‘On the importance of pseudonymous activity. You can see other blogs/discussions on the topic by searching the hashtag – #haleno (this works in google as well as twitter and facebook).

What I want to talk about in this blog is more about why reviewers reacted the way they did and why they are concerned about the actions of 2 authors (another author, Richard Brittain, recently attacked a reviewer with a wine bottle in Scotland).

I’ve seen posts on Facebook and in other forms of social media where it has been said (and I’m paraphrasing), “why are bloggers letting two people control their actions?” My initial reaction to that post was, why shouldn’t we freak out? I mean, two instances being reported in less than a week of reviews being stalked/attacked for simply expressing their opinion.

Now, I don’t know about you, but that kind of freaks me out a little bit – with my background in psychology, it could be hypothesized that for every reported incident there are multiple unreported. So for the two that were reported, there could be 10-20 unreported events, where authors who disagreed with bad reviews took some type of action against said reviewer. It could be something like:
• posting the negative review on their Facebook page and having friends/followers attack the reviewer
• attacking a review who didn’t understand their work (because obviously, if you give a book a negative review, it is because you didn’t understand it)
• posting an article in an online magazine about how reviewers are out to trash your book, or
• an article on how to avoid bad book reviewers (this happened to me several years ago when I started reviewing books on my blog).
Whatever the case may be, as a blogger, the action of these authors is making me reconsider my stance on reviewing, especially reviewing those that have been provided from the author.

2014-Blogger-blackoutThere was quite a bit of discussion throughout the blogging community on how we (the universal we) wanted to handle the situation. Were we going to quit blogging completely and lock blogs down? Would we limit reviews to authors who were well-established (although that in and of itself isn’t a guarantee of good behavior)? Or was there an alternative option? Ultimately, a review blackout was proposed and accepted by many bloggers and while we continued to discuss bookish things, no new book reviews would be published during an identified period. Some bloggers opted for a week-long blackout, others for longer. Katiebabs has a good discussion of the #BloggerBlackout HERE. Personally, I haven’t posted anything to my blog since Oct 22, although I have plenty of reviews that need to be published.

I’m not saying that I am going to quit blogging, not by a long shot, but I am going to be much more circumspect in accepting books for review and the policies that I will be applying when I screen books for review. This whole incident has also made me consider what precautionary measures, if any, I should take in order to protect myself. Recently, a blogger mentioned at a panel that she has contingency plans in place for her children should she be threatened by an author. For myself and others, our livelihoods could be affected, should be author, or fan decide to take action against a negative review. I’ve heard reports of workplaces being contacted by authors in an attempt to gain information about reviewers, for what purpose I don’t know (and do I really want to?) Ultimately, risking my career isn’t worth it for a hobby and that is just what blogging is to me, it is a hobby. One that I enjoy and want to continue (and will do so as long as I am able), but is it worth the risk?

Authors, SEO Specialist, Reviewers, Readers.. anyone who has been reading the news has seen the Hale incident. In response to this and many other incidents cropping up, have been brought together by AUTHOR CEO founder, Naomi Blackburn brought a group of us together for this Blog Train. Each of us are sharing a specific aspect of the issue as a positive response to the incident. We invite you to join with your own response


Posted by on November 5, 2014 in Blogging Community


Tags: , , , ,

7 responses to “A blogger’s response to Hale – #haleno

  1. Pavarti K Tyler

    November 5, 2014 at 3:01 pm

    I completely understand why bloggers feel this way. I know as an author, I’ve never had backlash because of a review I posted (some 3 and 4 star reviews even led to some great new friends). But because of what I’ve seen online, I’ve stopped posting reviews publicly. Sometimes I’ll do an endorsement publicly or a quick review on GoodReads but for critical reviews I only post as a part of the Awesome Indies team. No one knows which review came from which reviewer. I made this decision to protect my career. For bloggers to post publicly is a brave thing that I think authors should respect. It’s a scary world out there these days!

    • Dee

      November 5, 2014 at 7:27 pm

      unfortunately, it seems as though there is this belief that negative criticism may sink careers (I think someone else in the blog train touched on this) – i think its an interesting commentary on society right now in that the idea of failing seems foreign to people – i’ve picked up many books because of negative reviews (especially the ones where they say too much sex 😉 )

  2. Christine Nolfi

    November 5, 2014 at 6:58 pm

    Dee, many thanks for your thoughtful essay. Since the Hale incident, I’ve been heartsick to learn of bloggers thinking seriously about shutting down their blogs due to fear of out-of-control authors. If enough irrational scribes become stalkers, what happens to independent publishing? For my part, I never would’ve reached visibility without those first reviewers who were kind enough to take a chance on a debut novel. Even today, when I find a one-star review for one of my books on Goodreads or Amazon, I’m not thrilled … but I am grateful the reader took the time to read my work then post a review.

    • Dee

      November 5, 2014 at 7:25 pm

      or even if bloggers don’t shut down their blogs, many are already shying away from reviewing indie/self-pub’d authors – i hate seeing it and its sad that the actions of a few have long-lasting repercussions for the many – I’ve found many authors this way and I hate to see them hurt – so I don’t know where to go

  3. Lance

    November 5, 2014 at 8:28 pm

    Dee, this was an excellent post. I haven’t let that incident stop me from blogging. Like you, I love doing it and it’s a hobby – but I certainly don’t want to risk anything. In fact, I just got a couple of nasty comments and a threat to be called in because of legal action taken against an author.

    To be brief – I read and reviewed a fictional book about a man who is trying to save the Babe Ruth baseball league (similar to little league, 13-15 year olds) in a town. One of the characters in the book is a man who is the school principal who also is a sports agent, representing many professional athletes. In my review, I wrote that this character was really a stretch – who could do that kind of double duty and do them both competently?

    It turns out the author based this character on a real-life principal and it got a little too uncomfortable for that gentleman, so he has been scouring reviews of the book to make sure that nothing negative was said about him, and anything construed as such has recieved negative comments. Am I worried or scared? Not at all. Does it make feel bad that we as a society have come to this, along with authors threatening reviewers who post less than glowing reviews? Absolutely.

    • Dee

      November 5, 2014 at 10:39 pm

      you know – I never used to worry about negative reviews – but if an author were to show up on my doorstep that would probably scare the living daylights out of me

  4. Rachel Thompson

    November 6, 2014 at 2:08 am

    Thank you for your honest and thoughtful post, Dee. Reactions like that can be so scary. As an author, I’ve experienced stalkers (two of whom have threatened not only me but also my kids). That’s why I don’t share my personal info, location, or pix of my kids, and use fairly tight privacy settings on Facebook and other public channels.

    I suppose we just don’t know when a person is going to lose it, is really what it comes down to. Over a review, a post, something we write. Which is really damn sad, because what it comes down to is we are doing this because we love books, and writing, and reading.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: