RSS

Tag Archives: war

Audiobook Review – Maisie Dobbs – Jacqueline Winspear

maisie dobbsMaisie Dobbs
Author: Jacqueline Winspear
Series: #1 in the Maisie Dobbs series

Narrator: Rita Barrington
Run Time: 10 hrs
Producer: AudioGO

Description:
Maisie Dobbs isn’t just any young housemaid. Through her own natural intelligence–and the patronage of her benevolent employers–she works her way into college at Cambridge. When World War I breaks out, Maisie goes to the front as a nurse. It is there that she learns that coincidences are meaningful and the truth elusive. After the War, Maisie sets up on her own as a private investigator. But her very first assignment, seemingly an ordinary infidelity case, soon reveals a much deeper, darker web of secrets, which will force Maisie to revisit the horrors of the Great War and the love she left behind.

Review:
I had heard about this series through several of my online reading buddies who loved it – so when it was selected as a group read, I figured that it must have been a sign (since I didn’t really have any interest in either of the other books selected). I was looking forward to a lite mystery after reading a lot of dark, completely jacked up Nordic Noir mysteries and this was a great palate cleanser.

I loved the character of Maisie – she just seemed so unique in the current fiction world as it stands right now. And the time period is one of interest to me since there aren’t a lot of books written in the time period between WW1 and WW2 (that I have found). The mystery wasn’t so much of a mystery as a plot leading to a realization – or at least, that is how i saw it – while I didn’t know all the details that were revealed at the end, I had a 95% idea of what the result was going to be. But I honestly didn’t mind – for me, the best part of the book was seeing how Maisie Dobbs became Maisie Dobbs. The biggest surprise for me in the story was what happened to the love of her life during the war (but don’t worry, I try to keep my reviews spoiler free – so as not to ruin the book). It wasn’t what I was expecting and totally made me tear up.

However, one of my complaints was that while I liked that flashbacks were used – they were a bit chunky – I think the first flashback actually lasted a significant portion of the book – so when it jumped back to the present day I was a bit surprised/confused. I think it either would have been better to have broken the flash-backs up into some smaller portions – almost like an appetizer, rather than a whole entree – or write the first part of the book as her history up until when the mystery began. I think the former probably would have worked the best.

Unfortunately, my experience with the audiobook didn’t live up to the book itself and if I had had time, I might have stopped listening and read instead. I know that I nearly considered doing that with the rest of the series – because someone told me that the other books are narrated by someone else. I just did not enjoy the narrators voice. While I found that her female voices were passable – her male ones were like torture – I think I would have preferred a recitation rather than hearing her try to do male voices. It just didn’t work for me – which is unfortunately, because I think if done properly, this could have been a great audiobook (and the second one – review to follow in the future), was much improved. This is the first time that I have listened to anything by this narrator and it likely will be the last. I don’t think that I can fairly judge her on any other narrations after my feelings towards this one.

Overall, I’d give the book a solid 4 stars, but the narration only 1.5 – however, I do think that the book overall balanced out the mess of the narration – so 3.5 overall.

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on December 27, 2012 in Audiobook Review

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Review – Fifteen Days – Christie Blatchford

Fifteen Days: Stories of Bravery, Friendship, Life and Death from Inside the New Canadian Army
Author: Christie Blatchford

Narrated By: Matilda Novak
Run Time: 13 hours, 32 minutes

Book Description:
Long before she made her first trip to Afghanistan as an embedded reporter for The Globe and Mail, Christie Blatchford was already one of Canada’s most respected and eagerly read journalists. Her vivid prose, her unmistakable voice, her ability to connect emotionally with her subjects and readers, her hard-won and hard-nosed skills as a reporter–these had already established her as a household name. But with her many reports from Afghanistan, and in dozens of interviews with the returned members of the 1st Battalion, Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry and others back at home, she found the subject she was born to tackle. Her reporting of the conflict and her deeply empathetic observations of the men and women who wear the maple leaf are words for the ages, fit to stand alongside the nation’s best writing on war.

It is a testament to Christie Blatchford’s skills and integrity that along with the admiration of her readers, she won the respect and trust of the soldiers. They share breathtakingly honest accounts of their desire to serve, their willingness to confront fear and danger in the battlefield, their loyalty towards each other and the heartbreak occasioned by the loss of one of their own. Grounded in insights gained over the course of three trips to Afghanistan in 2006, and drawing on hundreds of hours of interviews not only with the servicemen and -women with whom she shared so much, but with their commanders and family members as well, Christie Blatchford creates a detailed, complex and deeply affecting picture of military life in the twenty-first century.

Book Review:
Normally, I am really bad about getting my audiobook reviews done as soon as I finish a book, because I have so many other things going on, but this book affected me on such an emotional level that I needed to write about it. While listening to Fifteen Days, on my commute to and from work for the past week, I literally spent every day in tears driving, I felt like I was so emotionally connected to the writing in the book.

I think that one of the reasons I was so emotionally invested in the book, is that I did a deployment to Iraq and many of the methods used by the Taliban in Afghanistan that resulted in Canadian casualties – I also saw in Iraq. One of which was the use of IED’s…so when they talked about stuff like that in the book – I could visualize the damage that they did to vehicles, the same with the damage inflicted by suicide bombers and other methods. If I had known how emotionally involved I was going to be in this book, I honestly don’t know if I would have picked it up. If nothing else, it did make me realize that while I have been back in the US for over 3 years now, what you face over there never truely leaves your mind – you might think that you can pick up and go on, but its not that easy.

But not only did the author spend time with the soliders, she also talked to their families. Interspersed through-out the book were recollections from the spouses and parents of the soldiers killed – what they were doing on the day that the Officer and the Padre came to visit them to tell them the news. How they had to go and tell their children – some of them hours away at military school, some only toddlers – the experiences ran the gammit. Ironcially, the last chapter of the book, where the various soldiers are travelling to memorial ceremonies all over Canada was actually the least emotional for me – I honestly feel that by the time I got to that point, I was so emotionally exhausted and drained that I couldn’t be upset anymore.

One of the good things about listening to a non-fiction book is that the narrator doesn’t have to try and use the multitude of different voices as they would in a fiction book. That being said, Matila Novak’s narration blew me away. She sounded like she was so connected with the writing, that everything just flowed. I did appreciate the places where she used specific voices (when there were quotes of British soldiers vice the normal Canadians) and a few other places. I will definately be seeking out her narrations again in the future and would like to see how she handles a fiction narration.

I highly recommend this book if anyone is curious about reading what not only our troops, but those of other countries have gone through in Afghanistan, and also, in Iraq. One thing I would caution readers is that the author didn’t take a typical chronological approach in the book, and the fifteen days highlighted actually jump back and forth. In the preface she explains why she did this and to me, the jumble, made it all seem more realistic – there are certain days on any deployment that stand out more than others, and her method of writing highlighted this. But at the same time, if the reader chooses to do it chronologically, they easily could, because each chapter starts with the dates. 5 stars for me on an emotional level and for this book, that is what counts the most.

 
Leave a comment

Posted by on July 14, 2012 in Book Review

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 358 other followers